Skip to content

Just A Babbling Brook

Musings on policy, philosophy, and all things judging

Header Image

Category: Tribal Knowledge

Team Leading, tournament best practices, Tribal Knowledge

A Team Leading rubric

December 20, 2025December 21, 2025 | brookgd

TLDR: Grading rubric for TLing exists here and here; I am not the author; I hope you find them helpful. At a recent event, I spoke with some newer judges about team leading. Most often, team leading is a judge’s first step up from floor judging. Being selected for a team lead (often abbreviated as ‘TL’) […]

Read more.

tournament best practices, Tribal Knowledge

You Simply Must Stop Working For Free

March 19, 2025March 19, 2025 | brookgd

Judges are great. They are, simply put, The Best. I love judges. Throw enough judges at any problem — any problem — and they’ll solve it. Judges are inventive, dedicated, selfless, and perhaps above all, selflessly dedicated. We tend to be willing to jump in at a moment’s notice to tackle the problem, whatever it […]

Read more.

Feedback, Old Man Walks Memory Lane, Tribal Knowledge

A Lagging Indicator

June 30, 2024July 7, 2024 | brookgd

This is a story about the best piece of advice anyone ever gave me. It was from one of my first mentors, Scott Shapiro-Neiwert, and is nearly as true in life as it is in judging. I was certified as a judge at a conference when Scott and a bunch of other judges traveled quite […]

Read more.

Top8, tournament best practices, Tribal Knowledge

Cutting to Top8

June 27, 2024June 28, 2024 | brookgd

So, you got to HJ your first event with multiple judges. Congratulations! That’s quite a feather in the cap. You got your briefing out before the event, took a couple appeals, and guided the event through the Swiss rounds. You even remembered to take some notes so you’re ready to write a review or two […]

Read more.

Recent Posts

  • A Team Leading rubric
  • The Calls of Regional Championship Bologna
  • You Simply Must Stop Working For Free
  • Stepping Away From The Table
  • Setting up Melee for Floor Judging
Need help with your own blog? Contact us!