Judge!!!!!!!!!!!

You’re a floor judge called over to a table at your local RPTQ. It’s the end of round 4 of 5. This is table 7. Players are in game three.

Player’s agree it’s turn five and their graveyards are in the order things were played. Jund was on the play.

Currently Abrupt Decay is on the stack targeting EE.

The Grixis player thinks his opponent has drawn an extra card at some point.

 

Is there anything wrong? What penalties are issued, if any? How do you communicate what’s going on to the players?

How do you ask the questions? Do you need to call your head judge? What other information do you need to make a decision on how to proceed?

 

Solution will be posed in a week.