(Originally published on 2026-11-11; last reviewed on 2026-11-11; last updated on 2026-11-11)
With each new set release, Wizards of the Coast update the Comprehensive Rules (CR) and the Oracle text of any number of cards. These updates include support for new mechanics, error fixes, and improvements to the wording of rules and cards. Wizards of the Coast also publish an update bulletin which summarizes and explains these changes.
This article is my own version of such an update bulletin. It lists all changes the Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update makes to the Comprehensive Rules, prerelease errata for Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit cards, changes to existing Oracle text, and changes to Gatherer rulings. For each item, I describe the change, its primary consequences, side effects, and anything else I find noteworthy. If I think that the update omits rules support or an erratum for a card or mechanic, the omission gets its own entry.
For the final section, I read Wizards of the Coast’s official bulletin and write down my impressions.
For more information, see Why Unofficial Update Bulletins?.
Disclaimer: I have no special insight into the inner workings of Wizards of the Coast or their rules team; any observations are based solely on the published updates and my own knowledge and understanding of Magic’s rules system. While I strive for completeness and correctness, I may miss some changes; in particular, my process for archiving and comparing Gatherer revisions is constantly evolving, just like Gatherer itself. (Then again, Wizards of the Coast purposefully omit minor changes in their own bulletins, so I think I’m still ahead.)
Table of contents
- Changes to the Comprehensive Rules
- Prerelease errata and outdated text
- Changes to Oracle text
- Gatherer rulings (nonfunctional)
- A look at the official update bulletin
Changes to the Comprehensive Rules
For this section, I recommend having a Comprehensive Rules diff open in another window, such as the one found on Academy Ruins.
Rules support for storied
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit release introduces the storied keyword ability.
The rules entry for storied is 702.195. Apart from the designation given to the player, the required number and qualities of the permanents, and storied appearing only on permanent cards, it functions identically to the older ascend keyword ability.
Rules support for recruit
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit release introduces the recruit keyword action.
The rules entry for recruit is 701.70 and is self-explanatory.
Rules support for hone counters
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit release introduces hone counters.
The rules entry for hone counters is 122.1j and is self-explanatory. The existing rules 613.4c and 613.7c connect hone counters to layer 7c and define their timestamps.
605.1a: New criterion for activated mana abilities (functional)
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update introduces an additional criterion to rule 605.1a that an activated ability must fulfill to count as a mana ability.
Namely, neither the ability’s cost nor its effect may move cards to or from a library. This affects the abilities of:
- Charmed Pendant, Millikin, and Deranged Assistant (milling cards)
- Chromatic Sphere, Darkwater Egg, Mossfire Egg, Shadowblood Egg, Skycloud Egg, Sungrass Egg, and Selvala, Explorer Returned (drawing cards)
Except for Charmed Pendant, each card receives reminder text that its ability may be activated only as an instant (see below). Rulings on the cards’ Gatherer pages have not been updated and still proclaim the abilities to be mana abilities (see below).
In this section, I discuss how this rules change affects scenarios using the mentioned cards, and how it affects and fits into the existing design of the rule.
For additional material on this update, see the companion article.
The tricks are still out there
Regarding its practical impact, this update reminds me of the changes the Murders at Karlov Manor update made to the definition of the suspend keyword. Namely, it made playing the exiled card optional.
In a Twitter (currently X) post, then-Rules Manager Jess Dunks commented on this change. As I recall, the reasoning behind the change was to make suspend more intuitive and to avoid issues where the forced casting collides with an aspect of the casting process, such as a mandatory additional cost.
For example, if the exiled card is Fling, the player had to cast the card and they had to sacrifice a creature. If the additional cost is a mana payment, the player would have been forced to pay that mana if they already had the required mana in their mana pool; if they didn’t, however, they wouldn’t have been forced to activate mana abilities to produce the necessary mana [CR 118.3c].
Jess Dunks continued that many players weren’t familiar with these facts. Other parts of the casting process, such as figuring out whether a legal target exists, may also pose a challenge.
There’s also the question of what exactly happens if the spell can’t be cast. Does the game force the player to go through the actual process until they reach the step where they can’t continue, followed by reverting the whole thing and then skipping over the casting attempt? Or does the game look ahead and consider all the ways through the casting process, and only if it finds a legal one does it force the player to go through the process? What if the player has some agency, such as whether to activate mana abilities to make paying an additional cost possible? What if another player has some agency?
Jess Dunks made the reasonable conclusion that players won’t know this and shouldn’t be expected to know this. So, casting a suspended card was made optional. (Whether Wizards of the Coast or their rules team knew how this aspect of the rules system works was left open.)
From a rules enthusiast’s perspective, such changes are often negative, since they remove the intricate parts that make Magic’s rules system so fascinating. This wasn’t the case with the suspend change though, because it removed forced casting only from suspend, but not from the game as a whole.
A handful of cards, such as Omen Machine, still force a player to play a card if able, and that’s all a rules enthusiast needs. Changing suspend’s definition overall simplified and improved gameplay for players, without changing anything for rules enthusiasts, who don’t concern themselves with the probability of a scenario. (And I wonder how pressing the discussed issues were—how many actual games of Magic has this change improved?)
Similar to the suspend update, the likely reason behind the current change is a desire to eliminate scenarios where a library is manipulated during the casting of a spell or the activation of an ability.
Scenarios where Chromatic Sphere’s ability gets activated during the casting of a spell that ultimately must be rewound are a staple of the judging community. Adding Archmage Ascension and Panglacial Wurm results in casting a spell in the middle of casting another spell. And then there are scenarios where Selvala, Explorer Returned’s ability gets activated during the casting of a spell but fails to produce enough mana. And that spell may be Panglacial Wurm cast from the library.
How to resolve such scenarios is likely beyond most players’ knowledge. Thankfully, Wizards of the Coast have introduced this new criterion that keeps Chromatic Sphere, Selvala, and related cards out of the casting process.
(Unlike with the forced casting of spells, however, the Comprehensive Rules and the Infraction Procedure Guide provide instructions on how to handle such scenarios. So, these “rules issues” or “rules nightmares” were never those things—at best, they could be called “judge nightmares” because people keep bringing them up, often in an attempt to be clever or tricky, no matter how often those scenarios have been conclusively answered in the past.)
Just as the change to suspend’s definition didn’t eliminate the forced casting of spells but just its most common occurrence, this new change doesn’t altogether eliminate drawing or otherwise moving cards from a library during a mana ability’s activation or resolution. The new text of rule 605.1a even mentions the way to keep drawing cards: replacement effects.
Chromatic Sphere’s ability may not be a mana ability anymore, but simply substitute Pristine Talisman and add Lich, and we’re back to a mana ability that causes a card to be drawn during its resolution. Any mana ability that includes gaining life is fair game with Lich or Nefarious Lich.
Even more options become available if the mana ability deals damage, such as that of Caves of Koilos. With Crumbling Sanctuary, it becomes a mana ability that exiles the top card of one’s library. Angel of Suffering turns the damage into milling cards. If one is willing to go to three cards, a card like Pariah can redirect the damage to a variety of creatures, such as Swans of Bryn Argoll. How about drawing cards but with even more steps? Nefarious Lich or a non-double-faced copy of Enduring Angel can turn the damage into losing the game, which Lich’s Mirror or Stunning Reversal turns into cards drawn (and as a bonus, Lich’s Mirror shuffles the library).
While activating a mana ability, the non-double-faced copy of Enduring Angel can be used to turn paying life into drawing cards. Discarding a card like Darksteel Colossus shuffles the library. Discarding a card while being enchanted with Wheel of Sun and Moon puts a card on the bottom of the library. Last but not least, Ashiok, Wicked Manipulator turns paying life into exiling cards from the top of the library.
Evidently, drawing cards, milling cards, and all other kinds of library manipulation are still possible under the new rules. They just require more setup.
Well, what about the second aspect of Selvala, Explorer Returned’s ability: producing a variable amount of mana based on information its controller doesn’t know beforehand? Do the new rules prevent this from happening in some other way? No, of course they don’t.
While there are no more mana abilities that produce mana in such a way all by themselves, the right combination of cards can cause a mana ability to behave like Selvala’s.
Suppose Alex starts casting Obstinate Baloth while she controls Concordant Crossroads, Ashnod’s Altar, and Lumbering Battlement. Before paying the spell’s total cost, she activates the mana ability of Ashnod’s Altar and sacrifices Lumbering Battlement. This causes the card exiled with Lumbering Battlement to return to the battlefield: Mul Daya Channelers. If the top card of Alex’s library happens to be a land card, Mul Daya Channelers has a mana ability that will produce the green mana necessary for paying Obstinate Baloth’s total cost; if the top card is a nonland card, Alex won’t be able to pay the spell’s cost.
But why stop at information that may be unknown but at least is predetermined? How about a scenario where the mana production depends on an opponent’s decision?
Suppose Alex starts casting Obstinate Baloth while she controls Ashnod’s Altar, Earth Kingdom Jailer, and Greenweaver Druid. Before paying the spell’s total cost, she activates the mana ability of Ashnod’s Altar and sacrifices Earth Kingdom Jailer. This causes the card exiled with Earth Kingdom Jailer to return to the battlefield: Nona’s Suppression Bonds. Nona decides whether it returns to the battlefield enchanting Ashnod’s Altar or Greenweaver Druid. If Ashnod’s Altar becomes enchanted, Alex can still activate Greenweaver Druid’s mana ability and produce the required mana; if Greenweaver Druid becomes enchanted, Alex won’t be able to pay the spell’s cost.
How about a scenario where the outcome is truly random?
Suppose Alex starts casting Darksteel Colossus while she controls Ashnod’s Altar, Lumbering Battlement, and Alena, Kessig Trapper. Before paying the spell’s total cost, she activates the mana ability of Ashnod’s Altar and sacrifices Lumbering Battlement. This causes the card exiled with Lumbering Battlement to return to the battlefield: Vedalken Squirrel-Whacker. If Alex rolls a 5 or higher on the first roll, Vedalken Squirrel-Whacker’s power will be 5 or greater and Alena’s mana ability will produce enough mana for Alex to pay Darksteel Colossus’s total cost; if Alex rolls a 4 or lower, Alena’s mana ability won’t produce enough mana and Alex won’t be able to pay the spell’s cost.
Evidently, the production of uncertain amounts of mana is still possible during the mana ability step of the casting process. It just requires more setup.
So, this rules change improves gameplay by eliminating the most common scenarios involving a particular, troublesome aspect of the rules system. An overall win for players. Just like the change to suspend. It doesn’t outright eliminate that aspect though and still allows for rarer or more complex scenarios. A neutral outcome for rules enthusiasts. Just like the change to suspend.
Regarding judges, I cannot help but think that this update will have an overall negative outcome. Unlike the changes to suspend.
First, how many judge calls does this rules change actually help to avoid? With suspend, I can see how a player suspends an instant or sorcery card and several turn cycles later the game state has changed in such a way that they no longer want to cast it. (The release of Doctor Who Commander a couple of months before the suspend update probably accounts for most such occurrences.)
With Chromatic Sphere and Selvala, there are no accidents. A player has to deliberately make the decision to activate these abilities while casting a spell, rather than beforehand. This requires a certain amount of knowledge on the player’s part. (Calling it rules knowledge would be too generous for most.) Combined with the intentional activation, the most likely outcome (at Competitive Rules Enforcement Level) is Unsporting Conduct—Cheating. So why would anybody actually attempt this at an event? “Annoy the judges for the lulz” seems an underwhelming reward compared to the consequences.
Personally, I’ve never encountered anything that even approaches the classic Sphere or Selvala scenarios in nine years of judging and playing Magic (and four years of just playing before that). The only relevant scenario I recall is a 2014 (2015?) Modern PPTQ quarterfinal between Tron and Lantern, where the mana ability of Chromatic Sphere allowed the Tron player to draw a key card with the Lantern player being unable to mill that card in response. But that’s just my personal experience. If you, dear reader, want to share your own, leave a comment below.
Second are Sphere and Selvala scenarios not as an actual judge call, but as what-if scenarios presented to or by judges. Those I have encountered in various online places, judge and otherwise, and I fear that Chromatic Sphere, Selvala, and all the other cards will simply be replaced with the more elaborate setups I discussed above. There is likely a temporary reprieve while the less . . . creative among those that ask such questions figure out that Panglacial Wurm & Selvala has just become Panglacial Wurm & three or four other cards. Once that knowledge has spread, I expect the quantity of such “judge scares” to return to previous levels. Except that the setup becomes more complicated.
Mana abilities never change
Putting aside the practical consequences, how does the updated text itself fare?
Whether a specific activated ability is a mana ability should never change. This applies to the ability as a characteristic and by consequence to any particular activation of that ability. Otherwise, one activation might not use the stack and resolve immediately, while the next one goes on the stack and can be responded to. (This holds true for triggered mana abilities, too; see the Ixalan update.)
Additionally, the game state might change halfway through such that the ability becomes a mana ability or stops being one. Does an ability on the stack that’s now a mana ability stay there or does it resolve immediately? Is an ability that’s no longer a mana ability retroactively added to the stack?
The three existing criteria have been designed to support constant “mana-ability-ness.” They all function in a vacuum, independent of any specific game state. This means that looking at the ability as a characteristic should be enough, and one shouldn’t need to consider actual or hypothetical game states in which a player may activate that ability. Looking at the game state would even be counterproductive, since that implies that the mana-ability-ness of an ability can change over time.
Two questions arise from this design intent: “How does the new sentence about replacement effects affect this?” and “Does the new criterion follow this design intent?”
Regarding the first question, the new sentence about ignoring replacement effects (other than self-replacement effects) states that it applies to all four criteria. Let’s see how that affects the first three criteria.
“[D]oesn’t require a target”: Most abilities that require targets have a fixed number of targets. They always have those targets, regardless of the game state or any decisions made during the activation process.
Some abilities have a variable number of targets and some of those allow zero targets. This includes Priest of Forgotten Gods’s ability, which was the reason for the Ravnica Allegiance update changing “doesn’t have a target” to “doesn’t require a target” in rule 605.1a: the latter is always true, regardless of the number of targets chosen for the ability, as per rule 115.6.
There are no abilities with a self-replacement effect that changes, replaces, or adds to the ability’s targets, so this criterion is unaffected by the changes to rule 605.1a. This is unlikely to change, because such an ability would come with its own issues.
Suppose a hypothetical ability’s effect read “This creature deals 1 damage to target player. If you control five or more Treasures, it deals 3 damage to target creature instead.” That ability’s text specifies two targets, so if I activated that ability, I would always need to choose both targets. This makes sense insofar that the number of Treasures I control could change before the ability resolved, but it doesn’t seem intuitive because only one target could ever be affected by the ability’s effect.
While there are some spells with additional or alternative targets in a self-replacement effect, such as Fight with Fire, in those cases, the self-replacement effect applies if an alternative or additional cost is paid. That condition can be evaluated while the spell is cast and it cannot change afterward, which allows rule 601.2c to have the casting player choose only the targets that are actually needed.
Alternative and additional costs are rare for activated abilities, and determining whether some other condition is guaranteed to remain (un)fulfilled until the ability resolves can get tricky.
All in all, I don’t expect to see an ability that produces mana and also has a self-replacement effect that requires a target.
“[C]ould add mana to a player’s mana pool”: The word “could” does a lot for this criterion. Whether an ability produces mana may depend on the current game state, but as long as it could produce mana, it fulfills the criterion.
Granted, the word “could” is not well-defined. It hints at hypothetical scenarios, but what is the extent of those scenarios? Which parts of the game state may be changed and which parts remain constant? What if there’s a choice to be made while resolving the ability? Which choices are legal? Must the hypothetical game state even be possible with existing cards? (Most likely yes, though no relevant ability exists.) Must it be possible within the current game? (Most likely no.)
Thankfully, rule 605.2 helps a bit, and imagining a possible game state for any given mana ability shouldn’t be too complicated. (That the criterion looks at the ability’s resolution runs counter to the general idea of not considering potential activations and resolutions and the game states in which they happen; I address this in the companion article.)
Regarding self-replacement effects, there are mana abilities with a self-replacement effect that changes what mana is produced. However, none of those effects create mana on their own: they all merely increase the amount of mana the ability already produces or change the type of mana.
And even if a hypothetical self-replacement effect caused an ability to produce mana that wouldn’t do so otherwise, the “could add mana to a player’s mana pool” criterion on its own would already cover that self-replacement effect. So, this criterion is also unaffected by the changes to rule 605.1a.
“[N]ot a loyalty ability”: This is the easiest criterion. Rule 606.2 defines a loyalty ability by the presence of a loyalty symbol in its activation cost, and self-replacement effects cannot affect the activation cost.
Thus, all three existing criteria are unaffected by the changes to rule 605.1a. So far, so good.
Now for the second question: does the new criterion follow the design intent of the other three?
“[D]on’t move any card”: When compared with the “could add mana” criterion, the choice of “don’t move” over “couldn’t move” implies looking at the current game state. This would mean that an ability could be a mana ability at some times and not at other times. For example, if the controller of Chromatic Sphere has no cards in their library, the ability doesn’t move a card from that library, so it could be considered a mana ability.
On the other hand, the phrase “replacement effects that may apply” over “replacement effects that apply” implies looking at hypothetical game states. Or it could mean a combination of actual and hypothetical game states as in “evaluate self-replacement effects based on the actual game state but treat any optional self-replacement effects as mandatory.” The lack of any existing abilities with such a self-replacement effect doesn’t help in figuring out the intent behind the rule.
From a design perspective, the new criterion should definitely be a universal criterion, just as the other three and for the same reasons I discussed at the start of this section. It’s just the text of the Comprehensive Rules that isn’t particularly clear.
Also, why add a sentence about replacement effects at all? As discussed above, the game state in which an ability is activated shouldn’t affect whether that ability is a mana ability. But replacement effects can’t apply to an ability as a characteristic; they can apply only to events in the ability’s activation or resolution. So, if one considered replacement effects, one would have to choose a game state in which the ability is activated.
If the actual game state was considered, then the ability’s mana-ability-ness would change from game state to game state. If a hypothetical game state was considered instead, any number of abilities wouldn’t be mana abilities anymore, such as those discussed under The tricks are still out there. (And in that case, determining whether any given ability is a mana ability would require knowledge of cards with appropriate replacement effects and likely be beyond most players’ capabilities.)
It follows that replacement effects should be disregarded to maintain constant mana-ability-ness. This is inherent in the rule’s design, so mentioning replacement effects explicitly is unnecessary.
Self-replacement effects are a bit of an exception, because they appear in the ability’s text and are thus also part of the ability as a characteristic. One can evaluate them as part of that text, outside of any activation of the ability. Phrasing the criterion itself differently would have made this a lot clearer and it would have made the added sentence redundant.
Furthermore, the added sentence uses a negative phrasing (“Do not take into account replacement effects […]”) and doesn’t mention anything beyond replacement effects. Does this imply that by default, all things belonging to the actual game state should be taken into account, with the specific exception of non-self-replacement effects?
Suppose Alex activates Chromatic Sphere’s ability while she controls Spirit of the Labyrinth; if she has already drawn a card this turn, the ability won’t move a card from her library. The effect of Spirit of the Labyrinth’s ability is not a replacement effect though. Should it be considered when evaluating whether Chromatic Sphere’s ability is a mana ability?
From the design perspective, continuous effects that affect an ability’s activation or resolution and that are not replacement effects should also be disregarded, because they too apply only when the ability is activated. Rule 605.1a’s new text makes this less clear cut by mentioning replacement effects.
This issue seems unique to the new criterion, as I can’t think of a scenario where one of the other three criteria would be affected in such a way. Making the added sentence more comprehensive or not adding it at all (thus avoiding the implications) would have gone a long way toward making rule 605.1a’s new functionality clear.
Prepare for battle (mostly nonfunctional)
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update adds support for battles that aren’t Sieges; with one exception, the changes don’t affect the functionality of Sieges.
No such battle cards were printed in the Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit release, but the announcement of the Battle of Five Armies Co-Op Kit and the cards previewed for that product allow some speculation as to those new battles’ design.
Most likely, those battles are regular single-faced cards; they have no battle type at all; they are protected by their controller; and they don’t have an intrinsic ability that triggers when they are “defeated.”
The specific changes are as follows:
Defense 0
The first part of the update concerns the state-based action that causes a battle with defense 0 to be put into its owner’s graveyard.
The update restricts the existing action to apply only to Sieges, and introduces a second state-based action that applies to non-Siege battles. The new action puts battles into their owners’ graveyards regardless of any triggered abilities.
This part affects the existing action’s definition in rules 310.7 and 704.5v. New rules 310.8 and 704.5w define the new action; subsequent rules are renumbered accordingly. (Notably, former rule 704.5z becomes rule 704.5aa.) Rule 122.1g hasn’t been updated and still applies the older action to all battles, regardless of their battle type.
Protectors
The update’s second part concerns eligible protectors for a battle.
Rule 310.9a is broadened regarding battles with no battle type. Only the controller of such a battle can be its protector. Previously, that rule enforced this restriction only during the initial protector selection as the battle enters the battlefield; now, the restriction applies also when choosing a (new) protector for a battle already on the battlefield. This is a nonfunctional change since Sieges can’t lose their battle type without also losing the battle card type.
The language of the state-based action that makes a battle’s controller choose a (new) protector if the battle has no protector is updated accordingly. This affects rules 310.11 and 704.5x.
The state-based action that made a Siege’s controller choose a new protector if the current protector wasn’t one of their opponents is broadened. It now applies to all battles and has the battle’s controller choose an appropriate player as its protector. This affects rule 704.5y.
Notably, this is a functional change for Sieges. The previous version of this state-based action caused an issue in team formats such as Two-Headed Giant, where a player could end up protecting a Siege controlled by one of their teammates.
Suppose Alex and Anthony play a game of Two-Headed Giant against Nona and Nick. Alex controls Invasion of Ravnica, which is protected by Nona. Nick resolves Blatant Thievery and gains control of Invasion of Ravnica. Directly afterward, that Siege is still protected by Nona, who is a teammate (not an opponent) of its new controller.
The state-based action’s previous text, however, made the action apply only if the Siege’s controller was its protector; it did not account for teammates of the controller. As a result, Nona continued to be Invasion of Ravnica’s protector. Alex and Anthony could still attack that Siege, since it was protected by one of their opponents, and Nona and Nick could still block for it, since one of them protected it. Nona and Nick could not attack the Siege, but if it was defeated, Nick got the opportunity to cast it transformed. In other words, the players who could attack the Siege didn’t want to and the players who did, couldn’t.
The state-based action’s new text resolves this issue. After gaining control of Invasion of Ravnica, Nick has to choose Alex or Anthony as its new protector.
Miscellaneous
The update’s third part is a small rewrite of rule 310.12. It now states that only some battles are Sieges, rather than all of them.
The update’s fourth and final part is an addition to rule 506.4. If a battle’s protector changes, that battle is removed from combat. This is a nonfunctional change, since a Siege that’s attacked can change its protector only if its controller changes, which already removes the Siege from combat.
For additional material on this update, see the companion article.
722.3a: Typo fix (nonfunctional)
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update corrects a typo in rule 722.3a.
Card types, supertypes, and subtypes
New types: None.
Ability words
New ability words: None.
Glossary entries
New glossary entries: Enduring Story, Hone Counter, Recruit, and Storied.
Legal information
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update adds “The Hobbit” to the list of trademarks of Middle-earth Enterprises and updates the year of that copyright notice to 2026.
Prerelease errata and outdated text
Note: Most of the time, I list only the changed parts of a card’s Oracle text, rather than the complete text of the card.
All subtypes removed (functional)
Wizards of the Coast have issued a large number of prerelease errata which change subtypes to (as yet undefined) card types. These errata affect all cards newly printed in the Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit release, as well as all reprint versions that are part of the release.
The errata replace the em dash on the type line with a hyphen-minus. Since the Comprehensive Rules use a long dash to differentiate between card types and subtypes, removing the em dash automatically moves the former subtypes into the card-type part of the type line. See rule 205.3b.
As a result, each card printed with the creature card type and the Dwarf and Warrior subtypes now has the creature card type, two undefined card types named “dwarf” and “warrior,” and no subtypes. Other cards and reprint versions are affected accordingly.
The Misty Mountains Cold (functional)
Wizards of the Coast have issued a prerelease erratum for The Misty Mountains Cold’s text. The erratum removes all reminder text after the {T} and replaces it with identically worded rules text.
As a result, after the chapter ability’s other effects, the ability’s controller is instructed to sacrifice The Misty Mountains Cold and to then add one mana of any color.
Printed text
I, II, III, IV — Create a Treasure token. Then if you control four or more Treasures, sacrifice this Saga. If you do, create a 6/6 red Dragon creature token with flying. (A Treasure token is an artifact with “{T}
, Sacrifice this token: Add one mana of any color.”)Oracle text
I, II, III, IV – Create a Treasure token. Then if you control four or more Treasures, sacrifice this Saga. If you do, create a 6/6 red Dragon creature token with flying. (A Treasure token is an artifact with “{T}, Sacrifice this token: Add one mana of any color.”)
Triggered abilities trigger (nonfunctional)
The Secrets of Strixhaven update harmonized the text of abilities that cause abilities of specific objects to trigger an additional time. As a result, all such abilities use the template “If a triggered ability of [some object] triggers […].”
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit release features three cards whose printed text uses the now retired template “If an ability of [some object] triggers […].” Wizards of the Coast have issued prerelease errata for those cards.
This update applies to: Wizard’s Staff, Bifur, Melodic Rider, and Chief of the Wilds.
Printed text (example)
As long as you have an enduring story, if
anability of a Dwarf you control triggers, that ability triggers an additional time.Oracle text (example)
As long as you have an enduring story, if a triggered ability of a Dwarf you control triggers, that ability triggers an additional time.
Omitted erratum for Settle the Wreckage (nonfunctional)
If a card instructs a player to search a library for multiple cards with specific qualities, the standard template is “[a player] searches [a library] for up to [amount of] [quality] cards.”
The text of Settle the Wreckage doesn’t match that template.
Oracle text
Exile all attacking creatures target player controls. That player may search their library for that many basic land cards, put those cards onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle.
Omitted erratum for Dáin Ironfoot (nonfunctional)
Per the guidelines for self-references, if a character has a byname and their card features that byname in the card name, the character’s full name should be used for self-references.
The text of Dáin Ironfoot uses only the character’s first name, which doesn’t conform to those guidelines.
Oracle text
When Dáin enters, create a colorless Equipment artifact token named Axe with “Equipped creature gets +1/+0” and equip {2}. When you do, attach it to target creature you control.
Whenever Dáin attacks, each equipped attacking creature gains double strike until end of turn.
Omitted erratum for Bilbo’s Ring (nonfunctional)
The Edge of Eternities release introduced a shorter template for effects that let a player draw cards in exchange for life. Previously, the standard template was “You draw N cards and you lose N life.” The new template is “You draw N cards and lose N life.”
This new template has been applied to newly printed cards, as well as to existing cards that have been reprinted since the Edge of Eternities release.
The text of Bilbo’s Ring, however, has not been updated for its reprint in Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit Commander.
Oracle text
Whenever equipped creature attacks alone, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.
Great Goblin, Foul-Hearted (nonfunctional)
Wizards of the Coast have issued a prerelease erratum which adds reminder text for the amass keyword to Great Goblin, Foul-Hearted’s text.
Printed text
Whenever Great Goblin enters or attacks, amass Goblins 3.
Oracle text
Whenever Great Goblin enters or attacks, amass Goblins 3. (Put three +1/+1 counters on an Army you control. It’s also a Goblin. If you don’t control an Army, create a 0/0 black Goblin Army creature token first.)
Thorin, Company’s Leader (nonfunctional)
Wizards of the Coast have issued a prerelease erratum which adds reminder text for Treasure tokens to the text of Thorin, Company’s Leader.
Printed text
Whenever a Dwarf you control deals combat damage to a player or battle, create two Treasure tokens.
Oracle text
Whenever a Dwarf you control deals combat damage to a player or battle, create two Treasure tokens. (They’re artifacts with “{T}, Sacrifice this token: Add one mana of any color.”)
The One Ring (nonfunctional)
Wizards of the Coast have issued a prerelease erratum which adds Marta Nael to the illustration credit for the Middle-earth classic artist version of The One Ring.
Printed artist
Dan Frazier
Oracle artist
Marta Nael & Dan Frazier
Changes to Oracle text
Note: Most of the time, I list only the changed parts of a card’s Oracle text, rather than the complete text of the card.
Pronoun usage (nonfunctional)
Starting with the Magic: The Gathering | Marvel’s Spider Man release, legendary cards in Universes Beyond sets use gendered pronouns when referring to themselves.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update introduces gendered pronouns to the rules text of legendary cards reprinted in Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit Commander.
This update applies to: Witch-king of Angmar and Arwen, Mortal Queen.
Old text (example)
Discard a card: Witch-king of Angmar gains indestructible until end of turn. Tap
it.New text (example)
Discard a card: Witch-king of Angmar gains indestructible until end of turn. Tap him.
Reach reordered (nonfunctional)
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update changes the rules text of Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes and Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes Commander cards that have a keyword list with reach on it. Reach moves to the front of those lists: the new order is defender, then reach, then all other keywords (such as first strike, hexproof, menace, trample, and vigilance).
This update applies to: Ms. Marvel, Kamala Khan, Hawkeye, Master Marksman, Reptil, Dinomorpher, Spider-Man, To the Rescue, Mister Fantastic, Medusa, Inhuman Queen, and Hawkeye, Trick Shot.
Old text (example)
Vigilance, reach
New text (example)
Reach, vigilance
Entered [the battlefield] this turn (nonfunctional)
If the text of a card mentions or refers to a permanent that entered the battlefield during the current turn, it may use “entered this turn” or “entered the battlefield this turn.” The former is used if an action is performed on the permanent, if its information is used, if a permanent refers to itself, or if something else in the text serves as a reminder that the permanent entered the battlefield. The latter phrase is used in cases where only the act of entering the battlefield is checked and where the permanent is of no further interest.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update adds a “the battlefield” to the rules text of two Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes Commander cards whose printed text uses the wrong template.
This update applies to: Flying Drone and Fixer, Techno Terror.
Old text (example)
{1}{U}, {T}: Draw a card, then discard a card. This ability costs {1}{U} less to activate if another creature with flying entered under your control this turn.
New text (example)
{1}{U}, {T}: Draw a card, then discard a card. This ability costs {1}{U} less to activate if another creature with flying entered the battlefield under your control this turn.
Omitted update for Charmed Pendant (nonfunctional)
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update changes the definition of activated mana abilities (see above). As a result, Charmed Pendant’s ability is no longer a mana ability.
This makes the ability’s activation instruction (“Activate only as an instant.”) redundant. For consistency with other affected cards, this instruction should have been replaced with reminder text.
Oracle text
{T}, Mill a card: For each colored mana symbol in the milled card’s mana cost, add one mana of that color. Activate only as an instant. (For example, if the card’s mana cost is {3}{U}{U}{B}, you add {U}{U}{B}.)
Reintroduced: Reach reordered (nonfunctional)
The May 2026 update changed the rules text of several dozen cards by moving the reach keyword to the front of keyword lists. The new order was defender, then reach, then all other keywords (such as first strike, hexproof, menace, trample, and vigilance). As a result, the order of keywords was consistent across all Oracle texts (with the exception of Skysnare Spider).
The Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update reverted these changes.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update reverts the reversal. Combined with the Oracle text changes for Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes cards and Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes Commander cards (see above), this update establishes a consistent placement of reach in keyword lists (with the exception of Skysnare Spider).
This update applies to: Longbow Archer, Ancient Spider, Tel-Jilad Archers, Chancellor of the Tangle, Sentinel Spider, Ruric Thar, the Unbowed, Bassara Tower Archer, Bitterbow Sharpshooters, Ramunap Hydra, Zacama, Primal Calamity, Thantis, the Warweaver, Vivien, Champion of the Wilds, Flycatcher Giraffid, Vivien, Monsters’ Advocate, Elder Gargaroth, Colfenor, the Last Yew, Drider, Lolth, Spider Queen, Catti-brie of Mithral Hall, Halana and Alena, Partners, Invoke the Ancients, Weathered Sentinels, Wilson, Refined Grizzly, Hierophant Bio-Titan, Titania, Gaea Incarnate, Resistance Skywarden, Vorinclex, Legolas’s Quick Reflexes, Curious Altisaur, Owen Grady, Raptor Trainer, Izoni, Center of the Web, Harold and Bob, First Numens, Rumbleweed, Lion Umbra, Frilled Sparkshooter, Galewind Moose, Lumra, Bellow of the Woods, Finneas, Ace Archer, Short Bow, The Odd Acorn Gang, Rendmaw, Creaking Nest, Sire of Seven Deaths, Hazard of the Dunes, Thundering Broodwagon, Dragon Sniper, Ragnarok, Divine Deliverance, Balthier and Fran, Iron Giant, Rig for War, Amazing Spider-Man, Surris, Silk-Tech Vanguard, The Lion-Turtle, Pummeler for Hire, Rancorous Archaic, Magmablood Archaic, Wildgrowth Archaic, and Old-Growth Educator.
Old text (example)
Vigilance, reach
New text (example)
Reach, vigilance
Reintroduced: Use “as long as” as long as possible (nonfunctional)
The May 2026 update replaced an “if” in the rules text of two cards with “as long as,” which matches the standard template for such effects.
The Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update reverted these changes.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update reverts the reversal.
This update applies to: Palladia-Mors, the Ruiner and Karakyk Guardian.
Old text (example)
Palladia-Mors has hexproof
ifit hasn’t dealt damage yet.New text (example)
Palladia-Mors has hexproof as long as it hasn’t dealt damage yet.
Reintroduced: Elvish Spirit Guide (nonfunctional)
The May 2026 update replaced the self-reference in Elvish Spirit Guide‘s rules text with a self-reference that matches the guidelines for self-references.
The Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update reverted this change.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update reverts the reversal.
Old text
Exile this
creaturefrom your hand: Add {G}.New text
Exile this card from your hand: Add {G}.
Reintroduced: Uvilda, Dean of Perfection (nonfunctional)
The May 2026 update replaced hone counters in Uvilda, Dean of Perfection’s rules text with refine counters. This wasn’t a functional change, since nothing else referred to either kind of counter.
The Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update reverted this change.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update reverts the reversal. Without a way to move refine counters from the exiled card to a permanent (or a way to put the exiled card onto the battlefield with its counters intact), this remains a nonfunctional change.
The rulings on Uvilda’s Gatherer page still refer to hone counters though (see below).
Old text
{T}: You may exile an instant or sorcery card from your hand and put three
honecounters on it. It gains “At the beginning of your upkeep, if this card is exiled, remove ahonecounter from it” and “When the lasthonecounter is removed from this card, if it’s exiled, you may cast it. It costs {4} less to cast this way.”New text
{T}: You may exile an instant or sorcery card from your hand and put three refine counters on it. It gains “At the beginning of your upkeep, if this card is exiled, remove a refine counter from it” and “When the last refine counter is removed from this card, if it’s exiled, you may cast it. It costs {4} less to cast this way.”
Reintroduced: Motivated Pony (nonfunctional)
The May 2026 update restored a “the battlefield” to Motivated Pony’s rules text. The new text matched the standard template for cases where only the act of entering the battlefield is checked.
The Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update reverted this change.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update reverts the reversal.
Old text
Whenever this creature attacks, attacking creatures get +1/+1 until end of turn. If a Food entered under your control this turn, untap those creatures and they get an additional +2/+2 until end of turn.
New text
Whenever this creature attacks, attacking creatures get +1/+1 until end of turn. If a Food entered the battlefield under your control this turn, untap those creatures and they get an additional +2/+2 until end of turn.
Reintroduced: Read this reminder only as an instant (nonfunctional)
The May 2026 update added reminder text to four cards with a mana-producing ability that is not a mana ability. The reminder text stated that those abilities may be activated only as an instant.
The Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update reverted these changes.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update reverts the reversal.
This update applies to: Deathrite Shaman, Priest of Forgotten Gods, Radiant Lotus, and The Warring Triad.
Old text (example)
{T}: Exile target land card from a graveyard. Add one mana of any color.
New text (example)
{T}: Exile target land card from a graveyard. Add one mana of any color. (Activate only as an instant.)
Gaslighting Reminder text for former mana abilities
The May 2026 update added reminder text to cards with a mana ability whose effect includes drawing cards or whose activation cost includes milling cards. The reminder text erroneously claimed that those abilities may be activated only as an instant.
The Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update reverted these changes.
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update reverts the reversal. Combined with the rules change to activated mana abilities (see above), the added text is not gaslighting text anymore, but actual reminder text.
Rulings on the cards’ Gatherer pages still proclaim those abilities to be mana abilities though (see below).
This update applies to: Chromatic Sphere, Darkwater Egg, Millikin, Mossfire Egg, Shadowblood Egg, Skycloud Egg, Sungrass Egg, Deranged Assistant, and Selvala, Explorer Returned.
Old text (example)
{1}, {T}, Sacrifice this artifact: Add one mana of any color. Draw a card.
New text (example)
{1}, {T}, Sacrifice this artifact: Add one mana of any color. Draw a card. (Activate only as an instant.)
Gatherer rulings (nonfunctional)
The Master of Lake-town
One ruling on The Master of Lake-town’s Gatherer page claims that both of its abilities trigger if The Master of Lake-town dies simultaneously with a player losing life. That part of the ruling is incorrect: only the dies ability triggers in such a case.
If The Master of Lake-town dies at the same time that a player loses life (for example, if it dies in combat and another creature dealt combat damage to a player), you choose the order for The Master of Lake-town’s two triggered abilities. If the mill effect resolves first, those cards—and also The Master of Lake-town—will be in graveyards before you determine how many cards to draw with its last ability.
When determining whether an event causes an ability to trigger, the default is to evaluate the game state directly after that event; for specific kinds of abilities, the game state directly before the event is evaluated instead [CR 603.10]. Leaves-the-battlefield abilities such as The Master of Lake-town’s third ability are one of those exceptions [CR 603.10a]. The Master of Lake-town’s second ability is not among the exceptions, so the game state after an event is used to determine whether that ability triggers.
If a player loses life at the same time that The Master of Lake-town dies, the dies ability looks at the previous game state; in that game state, The Master of Lake-town is still on the battlefield, so the dies ability triggers. The life-loss ability, on the other hand, looks at the game state after the event. After the event, The Master of Lake-town is not on the battlefield anymore, so that ability does not trigger.
The ruling also gives an example where The Master of Lake-town and a player are dealt combat damage during the same combat damage step. This is not an example of The Master of Lake-town dying simultaneously with a player losing life: first, as a result of the combat damage, the player loses life and damage is marked on The Master of Lake-town [CR 120.4]. After this event, The Master of Lake-town is still on the battlefield and its life-loss ability triggers. Then, state-based actions are performed and The Master of Lake-town is destroyed for having lethal damage marked on it [CR 510.3]. Since the events happen sequentially in the correct order, both abilities trigger. If the events actually happened at the same time, only one ability would trigger, as detailed above.
Settle the Wreckage
After a short break during the Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes update, the category “long-outdated ruling that hasn’t been corrected for the newest release” is back. This time, the honor goes to a ruling for Settle the Wreckage.
The ruling refers to a replacement effect that used to apply if a commander would be put into exile or a graveyard. The Core Set 2021 update removed that replacement effect in favor of a state-based action. Six years after that rules change, the ruling on Settle the Wreckage’s Gatherer page still refers to the previous rules set.
The number of lands that player may find is the number of attacking creatures that were exiled, even if some of those creatures were tokens, weren’t creature cards, or didn’t end up in exile (most likely because one was that player’s commander in the Commander variant).
Omitted updates for rulings on mana abilities
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update changes the definition of activated mana abilities (see above). As a result, several mana-producing abilities are no longer mana abilities.
Rulings that refer to that definition or to those abilities have not been changed; they still proclaim or imply that those abilities are mana abilities. This affects the following rulings on the Gatherer pages of the following cards:
Chromatic Sphere, Darkwater Egg, Mossfire Egg, Shadowblood Egg, Skycloud Egg, and Sungrass Egg
This is a mana ability, which means it can be activated as part of the process of casting a spell or activating another ability. If that happens you get the mana right away, but you don’t get to look at the drawn card until you have finished casting that spell or activating that ability.
If an effect allows you to look at the top card of your library any time or to play with the top card of your library revealed, and you activate Millikin’s mana ability while casting a spell, you can’t look at the new top card of your library until you are done casting the spell. The same is true if you activate Millikin’s ability while activating another ability.
Once Deranged Assistant’s ability has been activated, it can’t be reversed for any reason. If you activate it while casting a spell and discover you can’t produce enough mana to pay that spell’s costs, the spell is reversed. The spell returns to whatever zone you were casting it from. You may reverse other mana abilities you activated while casting the spell, but Deranged Assistant’s ability can’t be reversed. You’ll still have any mana the ability produced, and the milled card will still be in your graveyard.
Selvala’s parley ability is a mana ability. It doesn’t use the stack and can’t be responded to.
If you activate Selvala’s ability while casting a spell, and you discover you can’t produce enough mana to pay that spell’s costs, the spell is reversed. The spell returns to whatever zone you were casting it from. You may reverse other mana abilities you activated while casting the spell, but Selvala’s ability can’t be reversed. You’ll still have whatever mana that ability produced, and each player will have drawn a card.
The ability is still a mana ability (and doesn’t use the stack) even though you can only activate it when you could cast an instant.
While searching your library, you must keep your library in the same order until you shuffle it. This order could matter if you tap Millikin for mana, for example, to pay for a Panglacial Wurm you cast from your library.
You cast the card before shuffling your library (if it was searched). In some very rare cases, you may need to take actions involving your library while casting the card. For example, if it has an additional cost and you activate Deranged Assistant’s ability (“{T}, Put the top card of your library into your graveyard: Add {C}.”) to pay for it, you must maintain the order of your library while you search it.
Drain Power, Imprison, Pygmy Hippo, Tsabo’s Web, Burning-Tree Shaman, and Illusionist’s Bracers
A mana ability is an ability that (1) isn’t a loyalty ability, (2) doesn’t target, and (3) could add mana when it resolves.
A mana ability is an ability that (1) could add mana when it resolves, (2) isn’t a loyalty ability, and (3) doesn’t require a target.
An activated mana ability is one that adds mana as it resolves, doesn’t have a target, and isn’t a loyalty ability. A triggered mana ability is one that adds mana and triggers on an activated mana ability.
An activated mana ability is one that could add mana as it resolves, doesn’t have a target, and isn’t a loyalty ability. A triggered mana ability is one that could add mana and triggers on an activated mana ability.
An activated mana ability is one that could add mana as it resolves, doesn’t have a target, and isn’t a loyalty ability.
Nimble Obstructionist, Tale’s End, Kadena’s Silencer, and Sublime Epiphany
[…] An activated mana ability is one that could add mana as it resolves, doesn’t have a target, and isn’t a loyalty ability. A triggered mana ability is one that could add mana as it resolves and triggers on an activated mana ability.
Overcharged Amalgam, Midnight Arsonist, and Glen Elendra’s Answer
[…] An activated mana ability is one that could add mana as it resolves, doesn’t have a target, and isn’t a loyalty ability. A triggered mana ability is one that could add mana as it resolves and triggers based on an activated mana ability.
Mana abilities can’t be targeted. An activated mana ability is one that could produce mana as it resolves, doesn’t require a target, and isn’t a loyalty ability. A triggered mana ability is one that could produce mana as it resolves, triggers on the resolution of an activated mana ability or on mana being added, and doesn’t require a target.
Moonsilver Key and Raggadragga, Goreguts Boss
[…] Most mana abilities found on artifacts are activated mana abilities. An activated mana ability is an activated ability that could produce mana as it resolves, does not require a target, and isn’t a loyalty ability.
An activated ability that costs mana to activate is not a “mana ability” unless it could also produce mana and has no targets.
Omitted update for Uvilda, Dean of Perfection
The Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update replaces hone counters in Uvilda, Dean of Perfection’s rules text with refine counters (see above).
A ruling that refers to the counters has not been changed and still mentions hone counters.
After removing the last hone counter, casting the spell is optional. Timing permissions based on the card’s type are ignored. If an effect prohibits you from casting the card or you choose not to cast it, it remains exiled with no hone counters on it, and you won’t be able to cast it later.
A player with multiple graveyards
A ruling on returning previously exiled cards to the battlefield features a typo: it mentions Auras that are all owned by a single player but that are put into multiple graveyards. “Owner” should most likely be plural.
This issue applies to the Gatherer pages of: Elrond, Moon-Reader, Lake-town Mariners, and Roll-Roll-Roll-Roll. An almost identical ruling appears on the Gatherer page of Displace.
After each permanent returns to the battlefield, it will be a new object with no connection to the permanent that was exiled. It won’t be in combat or have any additional abilities it may have had when it was exiled. Any counters on it cease to exist; Auras attached to it are put into their owner’s [sic] graveyards; and any Equipment will become unattached.
Pronoun usage
Starting with the Magic: The Gathering | Marvel’s Spider Man release, legendary cards in Universes Beyond sets use gendered pronouns when referring to themselves. Wizards of the Coast also use gendered pronouns in rulings for those cards.
Rulings published for several legendary Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit cards use neuter pronouns rather than the pronouns appropriate for the character’s gender.
This issue applies to the Gatherer pages of: The Lord of the Eagles, The Master of Lake-town, Galion, Elvenking’s Butler, Bolg of the North, and Thranduil, the Elvenking.
Once a player has announced that they are casting The Lord of the Eagles, no player may take actions to try and change the power of creatures its controller controls before that spell’s cost is locked in.
The Master of Lake-town will usually be in a graveyard as its last ability resolves.
If The Master of Lake-town dies at the same time that a player loses life (for example, if it dies in combat and another creature dealt combat damage to a player), you choose the order for The Master of Lake-town’s two triggered abilities. If the mill effect resolves first, those cards—and also The Master of Lake-town—will be in graveyards before you determine how many cards to draw with its last ability.
As Galion’s ability resolves, the base power and toughness of the targeted creature are set to Galion’s actual power and toughness, not its base power and toughness. If Galion’s power or toughness changes later in the turn, the other creature isn’t affected.
Bolg of the North has a reflexive triggered ability. When it enters the battlefield, its triggered ability goes on the stack without a target. While that ability is resolving, you may sacrifice another creature. If you do, a second ability triggers and you pick a target that will be dealt damage. This is different from other abilities that say “If you do . . .” in that players may cast spells and activate abilities before a creature is sacrificed and then again after the creature is sacrificed but before damage is dealt.
Bolg of the North’s damage-dealing ability triggers only when you sacrifice a creature as a result of the instruction of its triggered ability. It won’t trigger if you sacrifice a creature for any other reason.
If Thranduil, the Elvenking gains a set of linked activated abilities (for example, one ability that exiles a card and another that refers to the card “exiled with” the object), that link only lasts for as long as Thranduil has those abilities. If it loses the abilities and then regains them, the link is lost.
Elrond, Moon-Reader
A ruling on Elrond, Moon-Reader’s Gatherer page features a typo: the quoted ability is missing a period.
An activated ability of a creature that’s also a mana ability (such as “{T}: Add {G}” [sic]) can cause Elrond’s first ability to trigger.
Riddles in the Dark
A ruling on Riddles in the Dark’s Gatherer page features a typo. (Finding that typo won’t be much of a riddle.)
You may split the cards into one pile of four and one pile of zero. The pile of four cards could be the face-up pile or the face-down pile. Which pile to choose won’t be much of riddle for your opponent if you do that!
Bard, King of Dale
A ruling on Bard, King of Dale’s Gatherer page features a typo: “Bard, King of Dale” should be plural.
Similarly, the effect of the last ability on multiple Bard, King of Dale [sic] is cumulative. If you control two, you’ll create four times the number of tokens.
Celebrate the Mountain-king
If a card has more than one ability, recent rulings take great care in specifying which ability they apply to, even if it is clear from the abilities’ text.
A ruling on Celebrate the Mountain-king’s Gatherer page doesn’t specify which of the two triggered abilities it applies to.
If Celebrate the Mountain-king leaves the battlefield before its triggered ability resolves, no nonland permanents will be exiled.
Mirkwood Meditator
A ruling on Mirkwood Meditator’s Gatherer page describes the effect that sets its power and toughness as “part” of the ability’s effect. That ability has no other effects though.
The ability of Mirkwood Meditator overwrites any previous effects that set its power and/or toughness to specific values. Other effects that set these characteristics to specific values that start to apply after the ability resolves will overwrite that part of the effect.
Thranduil’s Decree
One ruling on the Gatherer page of Thranduil’s Decree is proudly sponsored by Kheru Spellsnatcher.
Because you’re already casting the card using an alternative cost (by casting it without paying its mana cost), you can’t pay any other alternative costs for the card, including casting it face down using the morph ability. You can pay additional costs, such as kicker costs. If the card has any mandatory additional costs, you must pay those.
Radagast of Rhosgobel
One ruling on Radagast of Rhosgobel’s Gatherer page states that casting Radagast means that no other creature spell can be the first creature spell of that turn. This is correct as far as the effect of Radagast’s ability is concerned; in general, however, Radagast can be cast as the second or later creature spell of the turn, making another spell the first creature spell.
Radagast of Rhosgobel’s ability will look at the entire turn, even if Radagast wasn’t on the battlefield for some of it. Notably, if you cast Radagast of Rhosgobel in a turn, then no other creature spell you cast that turn can be your first.
Cost-reducing effects have a standard ruling on their interaction with alternative costs, additional costs, and other cost increases, as seen on Bilbo, Thief in the Night’s Gatherer page:
To determine the total cost of a spell, start with the mana cost or alternative cost you’re paying, add any cost increases, then apply any cost reductions (such as that of Bilbo, Thief in the Night). The mana value of the spell is determined only by its mana cost, no matter what the total cost to cast the spell was.
Radagast of Rhosgobel’s Gatherer page uses a pair of rulings instead that were last used on Hymn of the Wilds’s Gatherer page in 2016.
If there are additional costs to cast a spell, or if the cost to cast a spell is increased by an effect, apply those increases before applying cost reductions.
The cost reduction can apply to alternative costs.
Version-specific rulings
Continuing a trend started by the Lorwyn Eclipsed update, the Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update features more card versions with unique lists of rulings: Gatherer pages for specific reprint versions contain duplicates of existing rulings, which do not appear on pages for older versions.
This update applies to the Gatherer pages of the Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit versions of Settle the Wreckage and the Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit Commander version of Sauron, the Dark Lord.
A look at the official update bulletin
Having listed all the changes the Magic: The Gathering | The Hobbit update brings to the Comprehensive Rules and to Gatherer, it is time to conclude this article with my impressions of the official update bulletin.
As usual, the bulletin released after the updated Comprehensive Rules. So, any value it wants to provide must come from information that goes beyond what is readily apparent reading the Release Notes and the Comprehensive Rules. Also as usual, no such information is found in the bulletin.
Onward to individual items of note.
Non-Siege Battles (310.7, 310.8, 310.12)
The rules explain how Siege battles work, but not every battle will necessarily be a Siege! The battle rules have been updated with a new rule (310.8, explaining the state-based action that puts a non-Siege battle into its owner’s graveyard when its defense is 0). Subsequent rules are renumbered to accommodate this change. There are also minor updates for clarity.
Do the “minor updates” mean just the change to rule 310.12 or are the updates to other battle-related rules included? Because most of those updates are in fact new (if currently theoretical) information.
Mana Abilities (605.1a)
Mana abilities can be activated and resolved without using the stack during the casting of spells or resolution of abilities.
What about the activation of abilities and the resolution of spells? (Those things are correctly listed later in the text, so this part stands out even more.)
Similar situations can also occur when casting spells and looking at the top cards of your library with cards like Aetherworks Marvel or Future Sight.
Not sure how Future Sight plays into this. A spell cast using the effect of Future Sight’s ability moves to the stack as the first part of casting it [CR 601.2a], and the new top card of the library is not revealed until the casting process is complete [CR 401.5]. No other cards are looked at or revealed, so I fail to see how Chromatic Sphere complicated Future Sight in particular. I guess this lack of vision is why I’m an amateur rules enthusiast rather than a professional rules expert.
This is a functional change to the short list of cards below that have abilities that were previously mana abilities and no longer fit the criteria. […]
- Priest of Forgotten Gods
Priest of Forgotten Gods’s ability was never a mana ability. Surely, this is just a test to see if the reader is paying attention. Unfortunately, no one told the editor, so they updated (not corrected) the list sometime after the bulletin was first published:
Editor’s note: The list of cards affected by the change to rule 605.1a has been updated.
State-Based Actions (704.5v, w)
The state-based actions have been updated with the new rule for non-Siege battles, and subsequent state-based actions have been renumbered accordingly.
And the only functional change among the updates to battles doesn’t even get mentioned. What a pity.
Oracle Updates
The enduring story of Oracle updates continues with this release.
Well, technically all those updates have already happened once, back in May. But that was two-and-a-half months ago; in Magic time, that’s an eternity, so it certainly feels like a brand new thing.
Just a Reminder
The changes to mana abilities listed in the comprehensive rules section of this update bulletin resulted in a few additional bits of reminder text being added to cards that once had mana abilities but now quite reasonably do not. This way, when you check Gatherer, you’ll be able to quickly note that cards like Millikin have undergone some functional changes thanks to this rules update.
(Shouldn’t “comprehensive rules” be capitalized?)
And since everyone, after noting the reminder text, turns directly to the Comprehensive Rules rather than the rulings on the card’s Gatherer page, the now incorrect rulings on all those pages won’t cause any confusion whatsoever. So there’s clearly no reason to update or remove them.