Elite Arcanist and X Spell

You know what sounds fun? Getting rid of the 2 mana restriction on Isochron Scepter, and making it a creature. In Magic 2014, they did that, and gave us Elite Arcanist. Unlike his Scepter predecessor, Arcanist has no limit on the mana cost of the Instant he flings about willy-nilly, so you can happily put expensive and fun things on him to use every turn. But how does he work with X spells, like Sphinx’s Revelation? Do you get to pay mana into X? Do you get to decide what X is and get it for free? The answer to both is, sadly, no. Outside of the stack (which includes exile, where Arcanist keeps his spells), the value of X in a mana cost is always 0. So a Sphinx’s Revelation underneath your Arcanist always has a CMC of 0, and it’ll cost 3 mana to use Arcanist to cast a copy. The problem is, since you’re casting the copy for free, you aren’t ALLOWED to put anything into X, it must be 0. So Arcanist doesn’t work very well with X spells, since they’re not likely to do much! Do note that you’re still allowed to pay ADDITIONAL costs when you cast your free spells from Arcanist, just not alternate ones.

Sharing is Caring - Click Below to Share