In a 3rd round match of a Constructed PTQ Alan and Nick are ready for the first game of the match and draw their opening hands. After a short review both players decide to keep their opening hands. Alan opens the game with a Swamp and casts . While resolving the Alan notices Nick already has 8 cards in his hand instead of the supposed 7 and calls a judge. What would you do in this situation, what infraction and penalty has been commited and what, if any, would be your fix?

Read more.